Scientific Breakdown: The "Eggs Cause Cancer" News in India (Dec 2025)
The Context: In December 2025, a controversy erupted after a viral video claimed that a specific batch of eggs from a premium Indian brand (Eggoz) contained residues of a banned antibiotic. This led to widespread panic linking eggs to cancer.
1. The Core Scientific Reason: Antibiotic Residues
The primary reason for the news is not the egg itself, but a chemical contaminant found during lab testing.
- The Chemical Involved: The specific compound found is AOZ (3-amino-2-oxazolidinone). This is a metabolite (a breakdown product) of Nitrofuran antibiotics.
- Why it is a problem: Nitrofurans are a class of antibiotics that were historically used in poultry to prevent disease and promote growth. However, they are now banned in India (and globally) because they are classified as genotoxic carcinogens.
- Mechanism: "Genotoxic" means the chemical can damage the DNA within cells. "Carcinogenic" means this DNA damage can potentially lead to the formation of cancer over long periods of exposure.
2. Understanding the Risk Levels (Toxicology)
While the presence of the chemical is a regulatory violation, the immediate health risk is scientifically nuanced.
- The Dosage Detected: The viral lab report claimed to find AOZ at a level of roughly 0.73 ppb (parts per billion).
- Scientific Perspective: To put this in perspective, 0.73 ppb is an extremely minute trace amount. Toxicologists and doctors (including AIIMS experts) have clarified that while no amount of a banned substance is acceptable legally, this specific microscopic amount is unlikely to cause cancer in humans through normal dietary consumption. The cancer risk is typically associated with long-term exposure to much higher doses.
3. The "Bio-Accumulation" Factor
The news highlights a systemic issue in the poultry supply chain known as bio-accumulation.
- Even if a farmer does not feed antibiotics directly to the chicken, traces can enter the bird via contaminated water or feed corn that was treated with chemicals.
- These chemicals accumulate in the fat and tissues of the bird and are eventually passed into the egg yolk.
4. Secondary Research: Fatty Acids (Linoleic Acid)
Apart from the antibiotic scandal, some unrelated scientific discussions have conflated recent studies on fatty acids with this news.
- A separate study (published earlier in 2025) noted that Linoleic Acid, an omega-6 fatty acid found in many foods including vegetable oils, eggs, and nuts, could technically "fuel" the growth of certain existing tumors (like triple-negative breast cancer) in lab settings.
- Clarification: This does not mean eggs cause cancer. It refers to how specific cancer cells might utilize fat for energy. This is often misinterpreted in viral news as "eggs causing cancer."
Conclusion: Scientific Verdict
There is no scientific evidence that eating standard eggs causes cancer. The current news is driven by the detection of a banned antibiotic contaminant in one specific batch, not an inherent danger in eggs. The medical consensus advises that eggs remain a safe and highly nutritious source of protein, provided they are sourced from reliable suppliers who adhere to antibiotic-free standards.
Comments
Post a Comment